To address the safety concerns associated with the use of a cell phone while
driving, New York became the first state in the nation to prohibit the use of
hand-held cellular phones while driving, effective November 1,2001. In recent
years, the increased use of cell phones and their use while driving have brought
increased attention to the broader issue of distracted driving. Despite the
increased attention, information is limited with regard to the specific sources
of distracted driving that most frequently contribute to traffic crashes or how
widespread these distracting activities or behaviors may be within the driving
population.
To provide more information on these subjects, the Institute for Traffic
Safety Management and Research conducted a statewide telephone survey of New
York State licensed drivers in fall 2001 to collect information on cell phone
use and attitudes related to the new law prior to its implementation and to
identify the most frequent sources of distracted driving. The primary objective
of the survey was to provide information to the state's traffic safety community
for their use in the development of public policy, appropriate and effective
messages to raise public awareness of the dangers of distracted driving, and
other countermeasures. The survey will be repeated in fall 2002 to examine
changes in distracted driving over time, and in particular, changes in
awareness, attitudes, and reported use of cell phones between the pre-law and
post-law time periods.
SURVEY METHODOLOGY
The telephone survey was designed to provide representative measurements of
drivers' attitudes, behaviors, and experiences related to the use of cellular
telephones while driving, drivers' knowledge of the New York State law banning
hand-held cell phone use while driving, and to provide information about other
distractions while driving. The survey questionnaire was developed by the
Institute for Traffic Safety Management and Research (ITSMR), in consultation
with Governor George E. Pataki's Traffic Safety Committee. FactFinders, Inc.
assisted in the pilot test and refinement of the final questionnaire and
conducted all of the telephone interviews for the study.
Using a scientific random probability design based on random-digit dialing,
the sample comprised 805 respondents with valid New York State driver's
licenses. The sample was stratified to reflect the proportion of licensed
drivers residing in each of the state's 62 counties. The data analysis was
conducted by ITSMR with the use of SAS® software The statistical sampling error
ranges from +2.1 - +3.5
percentage points at the 95% confidence level. The Chi square test at a level of
significance of 0.05 was used to examine differences in responses by driver
demographic characteristics and other variables of interest.
SURVEY RESULTS
Cell Phones and Driving
The primary objectives of the survey questions on cell phones and driving
were: 1) to collect information on the use of cell phones while driving, 2) to
assess drivers' perceptions of safety problems associated with using cell phones
while driving, and 3) to determine the extent to which drivers were familiar
with the cell phone law prior to its implementation. The key findings of the
survey with regard to these objectives are summarized below.
Cell Phone Use While Driving
 |
Almost one-half (46%) of the survey respondents said that they have a cell
phone with them always or most of the time while driving. Of the drivers who
said that they have a cell phone in their vehicle at least some of the time: |
|
 |
12% use the phone very often, 20% use it sometimes, and 34% use the
phone once in a while |
|
 |
28% always or most of the time pull off to the side of the road to use
the cell phone |
 |
Of the drivers who reported using a cell phone while driving, one-half
said that they have a hands-free feature or adapter for their phone. Almost
two-thirds (64%) of the respondents who have a hands-free feature or adapter
said that they always/most of the time use it. |
 |
The most commonly cited reasons given by the survey respondents for using
a cell phone while driving were family matters (34%), business (25%), and to
report emergencies (23%). |
 |
Significantly greater proportions of drivers on Long Island and in New
York City than in the Upstate region had cell phones with them in their
vehicles (66%, 61 %, and 51 %, respectively, and owned hands-free features
or adapters for the phones (61%, 58%, and 40%, respectively). |
 |
Men were more likely than women to use a cell phone very often or
sometimes while driving (39% vs. 26%) and to have a hands-free adapter for
their phone (55% vs. 45%). |
 |
Drivers in the younger age groups (16-34 and 35-44 years) were much more
likely than older drivers to have cell phones in their vehicle, use them
frequently while driving, and to have hands-free adapters. |
 |
Hispanic drivers were more likely to have a hands-free adapter for their
phones (69%) than were African-American drivers (63%) or White drivers
(45%). |
 |
Of the every day drivers, 35% said that they use their cell phone very
often or sometimes while driving. |
 |
Drivers of mini-vans, SUVs, and pick-up trucks were more likely than
drivers of passenger cars to have cell phones in their vehicles (67% vs.
52%). |
Perception of Safety Problems Associated with Using Cell Phones While
Driving
 |
The majority of drivers (58%) thought that dialing the phone was the part
of cell phone usage most likely to distract a driver or take his attention
away from driving, followed by holding a conversation (22%). |
 |
Four of five drivers who have a cell phone in their vehicle believe that
dialing is the most distracting part of cell phone use, compared to one of
two drivers who never have a phone in their vehicle. |
 |
Almost two-thirds (64%) of all drivers surveyed said that, in their
opinion, using a cell phone while driving affects a driver's ability to
drive safely a great deal; an additional 31 % said it affects safety
somewhat. |
 |
Drivers in the younger age groups (16-34 and 35-44) were much less likely
(58%) to perceive that cell phones affect driving safely a great deal than
were drivers 55 years and older (75%). |
 |
Hispanic drivers (82%) were much more likely to believe that cell phones
affect the ability to drive safely by a great deal than White (64%) or
African-American (58%) drivers. |
 |
Drivers who never have a phone in their vehicle were much more likely than
drivers who always/most of the time/sometimes have a phone in their vehicle
to believe that cell phone use affects the ability to drive safely a great
deal (75% vs. 58%). |
Familiarity with New York's Cell Phone Law
 |
Nine of ten survey respondents said that they had seen, read, or heard
about New York's new law banning the use of hand-held cell phones while
driving. |
 |
Drivers 16-34 years old were somewhat less likely than older drivers to be
familiar with the new law prohibiting hands-free cell phone use while
driving. |
Other Driver Distractions
Because using a cell phone while driving is only one form of distracted
driving, the survey included two questions to identify other frequent sources of
distracted driving. Key findings include:
 |
25% of the respondents said that they very often change the radio, CD, or
tapes; 18% very often adjust the heat or air conditioning, 12% very often
eat or drink while driving, 9% daydream, and 5% deal with a child's need or
problem. |
 |
55% said cell phone use was the most unsafe distracting behavior; an
additional 15% identified it as the second most distracting behavior. |
Crashes Associated with Distracted Driving
Since limited information is available in the literature with regard to the
specific sources of distracted driving that most frequently contribute to
traffic crashes, the survey contained three questions designed to collect
information on the extent to which drivers had ever had or almost had an
accident due to their own distracted driving and/or due to another driver using
a cell phone. Key findings include:
Distracted Driving and Involvement in a Crash
 |
12% of the respondents said they had an accident because they were
distracted or their attention was taken away from driving. Of those who had
been distracted and crashed: |
|
 |
49% indicated they had been daydreaming or not paying attention |
|
 |
13% named other passengers arguing or talking as the cause of the
distraction |
|
 |
9% noted other drivers' unsafe driving |
 |
Men were more likely than women to report that they had been in an
accident due to their own distracted driving (15% vs. 9%). |
 |
Drivers 35-44 years old were most likely to report that they had an
accident due to their own distracted driving (51 %), while drivers 55 years
and older were least likely to have had such an accident (38%). |
Distracted Driving and Almost Involved in a Crash
 |
43% of the respondents said that they almost had an accident because they
were distracted. Of those who had almost had a crash as a result of being
distracted: |
|
 |
40% noted daydreaming or not paying attention as the distraction |
|
 |
16% cited dealing with a child's need or problem |
|
 |
15% noted other passengers |
|
 |
6% reported cell phone use |
 |
Similar proportion of Upstate drivers (47%) and those on Long Island (47%)
said they had almost had an accident because they were distracted, compared
to 35 percent of drivers from New York City. |
 |
Male drivers (52%), and White drivers (48%) were most likely to have
almost had an accident due to their own distracted driving. |
Crash Involvement Due to Another Driver Using a Cell Phone
 |
27% of the respondents said that they had or almost had an accident
because another driver was using a cell phone. |
 |
Drivers 16-24 years old were more than twice as likely to have had or
almost had an accident due to another driver using a cell phone than drivers
55 years and older (38% and 15%, respectively). |
 |
Hispanic drivers were most likely (46%) to have had or almost had an
accident due to another driver using a cell phone, followed by
African-American drivers (35%), and White drivers (24%). |
|